Home / 比較
SillyTavern vs CharClub
SillyTavern edges CharClub on our editorial score (4.3 vs 3.6), but SillyTavern is the better fit if you want live voice calls and long-term memory and image sharing; CharClub has no clear edge there.
0| SillyTavern0 | CharClub0 | |
|---|---|---|
| 編集スコア | 4.3 / 5 | 3.6 / 5 |
| 価格 | Free | $9.99/mo |
| 価格帯 | Free | Under $10/mo |
| 無料プラン | あり | あり |
| 価格の詳細 | Free and open source under AGPL-3.0. You pay only for whichever model API you connect. | App-store data (2026-09): unlimited free daily messages; Pro $9.99/mo removes ads and coin gating. The website is a Web3 pitch shell; the Android app is the real product. |
| アダルトコンテンツ | Optional mature mode | Optional mature mode |
| 音声 | ライブ通話 | なし |
| 画像 | あり | なし |
| 動画 | なし | なし |
| 記憶 | あり | なし |
| カスタムキャラクター | あり | あり |
| コンパニオンの種類 | Any character | Female companion, Male companion |
| プラットフォーム | Desktop, Web | Web, Android |
| ローカル動作 | あり | なし |
SillyTavern — 私たちの見解
If you want total control and zero subscription, this is where the advanced users live.
- Complete control over prompt and memory
- Works with local or hosted models
- Free forever
CharClub — 私たちの見解
Unlimited free messages across a 160k-download character app — just tolerate the ads and the Web3-flavoured website.
- Unlimited free messages
- Large anime/K-pop/celebrity library
- Actively updated
SillyTavern vs CharClub — よくある質問
Which is cheaper, SillyTavern or CharClub?
SillyTavern is the cheaper of the two at Free, against $9.99/mo for CharClub.
Which one has a free tier?
Both do — you can try either without paying.
Which remembers conversations better?
SillyTavern retains context across sessions; CharClub keeps context only within a session.
Which handles adult content differently?
SillyTavern: Optional mature mode. CharClub: Optional mature mode. This directory is SFW — we record whether a mature mode exists so you know before signing up, and we describe no explicit material.