Home / Compare
Pi vs My Softly
Pi edges My Softly on our editorial score (4.0 vs 4.0), but Pi is the stronger pick if you want live voice calls, while My Softly fits better if voice notes or image sharing or custom characters matter more.
0| Pi0 | My Softly0 | |
|---|---|---|
| Editor score | 4.0 / 5 | 4.0 / 5 |
| Price | Free | $13.33/mo |
| Price band | Free | $10–20/mo |
| Free tier | Yes | Yes |
| Price detail | Free, with no usage limit and no paid tier — no card required. | Verified (2026-09): Premium $15.99/mo or $159.99/yr (~$13.33/mo), flat with no token meter; optional photo/voice packs $2.99-$12.99. iOS only, 6 countries at launch. |
| Adult content | No adult mode | No adult mode |
| Voice | Live calls | Voice notes |
| Images | No | Yes |
| Video | No | No |
| Memory | Yes | Yes |
| Custom characters | No | Yes |
| Companion types | Any character | Male companion |
| Platforms | Web, iOS, Android | iOS |
| Runs locally | No | No |
Pi — our take
Completely free, genuinely warm, and no upsell wall. Not a roleplay product, but an excellent listener.
- Entirely free with unlimited voice
- Consistently rated the most empathetic free model
- No ads
My Softly — our take
Memory-first, strictly safe-for-work AI boyfriend with proactive check-ins — a rare no-NSFW option for iPhone.
- Proactive texts-first check-ins
- Strictly SFW with real privacy controls
- Flat subscription, no coins
Pi vs My Softly — common questions
Which is cheaper, Pi or My Softly?
Pi is the cheaper of the two at Free, against $13.33/mo for My Softly.
Which one has a free tier?
Both do — you can try either without paying.
Which remembers conversations better?
Both keep context across sessions. The practical difference is elsewhere: voice support differs between them.
Which handles adult content differently?
Pi: No adult mode. My Softly: No adult mode. This directory is SFW — we record whether a mature mode exists so you know before signing up, and we describe no explicit material.